Skip navigation
 
Motorbikes 12

When modern technology goes bad

Personally, I hate all new technology, without exception. Well, except anything that allows me to be lazier than I already am.

So, yes, I will grudgingly admit that new technology can be a wonderful thing, when it works. At Estoril last weekend there were two fascinating instances of new technology not doing the right thing.

In the race Nicky Hayden’s electronics went berserk, giving him one of the scariest rides of his career. Apparently his Ducati GP12 got lost – it suffered a GPS glitch so it didn’t know where it was on the racetrack.

motogp  When modern technology goes bad

When Hayden was at Turn One his GP12 thought it was at Turn Four and when he was on the brakes the traction control was cutting in. Maybe the bike thought it was back home at Mugello or perhaps the satnav in his crew’s rental car had confused the GPS so the bike was trying to find its way back to the team’s hotel.

“It was quite dangerous, especially at the last corner,” said the American. “When I opened the throttle there all of a sudden I’d lose power, the weight distribution would change and I’d almost lose the front.”

motogp  When modern technology goes bad

Surely this is a sign that electronics have gone far too far in MotoGP? Most of the riders agree. They want the control in their hands, not in a little black box. Riders like Hayden, Casey Stoner, Ben Spies and Valentino Rossi all agree they’d prefer less electronics.

Maybe now is the time to start restricting the technology, creating traction control systems that are designed purely to improve safety rather than enhance performance. Banning onboard GPS – which allows the bike to adjust throttle response, traction control, engine braking and so on for each individual corner – might be a good place to start.

The other example of technology doing bad things at Estoril occurred in the media centre, of all places.

Like all technology, the internet is amoral. Like nuclear power it can be used for good or for ill. In the media world it increases pressure on journalists to come up with attention-grabbing headlines. Instead of needing one big headline a day or one big headline a week, there’s pressure to come up with a big headline every few hours. Thus the temptation to not let the facts get in the way of a good story increases several fold.

So it was last week with the Casey Stoner retirement headlines. This story appeared first on a Spanish website and then in the Spanish press. It grew from the revelation – leaked to the press by Repsol Honda management – that Stoner had turned down the offer of a new two-year contract for 2013 and 2014. (There is a Machiavellian sub-text to this revelation which I can’t be bothered to go into here.) Instead the reigning MotoGP champ told his employers that he would prefer a one-year contract.

motogp  When modern technology goes bad

Some journalists took this information and ran with it – speculating that Stoner was already considering retirement. Nonsense, of course.

Top riders often prefer one-year deals because it keeps them more in control of the situation. Other riders concerned about their future potential are more likely to want the added security of a two-year contract. Stoner’s childhood hero Mick Doohan often preferred one-year deals. It allowed him to renegotiate more often and usually in his favour. It also allows the rider more flexibility in case things change, either with his employers or at a rival factory.

Inevitably the subject of Stoner’s ‘retirement’ came up during a press conference at Estoril. The man in the spotlight treated the rumours with disdain.

“Everyone in MotoGP seems good at making up stories,” he said. “I’ve said many times I’m not going to have a long career and at the moment I haven’t decided what I’m doing next year. But until you hear it from my mouth – don’t believe what you read. I’m certainly not thinking about retirement at this point.”

motogp  When modern technology goes bad

When one of the journalists who had splashed the retirement story on his front page asked Stoner a question, the Aussie looked him straight in the eye and said “Don’t read what you produce”.

It was a genius put-down and reminiscent of Doohan in his glory days. Doohan took no prisoners in his dealings with the press and struck terror into many journalists who crossed him. On one occasion he reduced a journalist to tears with a scornful reply to a stupid question.

I well remember his reply to another journalist, who had dared to express doubt about something Doohan had said. “Are you calling me a liar?!” asked the five-time 500 World Champion.

Then there was the press conference – in Argentina, I think – during which he tired of a local journalist’s persistent line of questioning. Doohan clammed up and reverted to WW2-style name-rank-and-number replies. “My name is Mick Doohan and I am competing in the Argentine Grand Prix for the Repsol Honda team,” he said with one of his scary glares.

Of course, it’s not impossible that Stoner might retire at the end of next year. He’s already said that he won’t stick around long enough to emulate Doohan’s five titles and he makes no secret of the fact that he’d much rather be home on the family farm in New South Wales, making babies, hunting wild pigs and thrashing around on dirt bikes than endlessly circulating the globe. At the some point the joy of racing the world’s trickest motorcycles will be outweighed by the ennui of aeroplanes, hire cars and hotel rooms. It happens to every racer eventually.

This is four-time 500 champ and home-loving Californian Eddie Lawson on the subject. “I hated the travelling so much. That last year [1992] I’d sit at home, thinking about going to Europe, thinking ‘I can’t get out of the chair to go’. When you’re young the travelling is okay, but I’d had ten years doing 50 international flights a year. I’d had enough.”

This year is Stoner’s 11th season of Grand Prix racing.

Add your comments

12 comments on When modern technology goes bad

  1. Gavin Brown, 10 May 2012 11:27

    Agree about the technology. I feel the edge has been taken off MotoGP at the moment. And if it’s there for safety, well, I still see a lot of accidents due to loss of traction, so that excuse doesn’t really work.

    As for Stoner, I’m not his biggest fan. But the sport needs him right now so I hope he sticks around…

  2. noahracer, 10 May 2012 13:57

    Great read, Mat.

  3. Rich Ambroson, 10 May 2012 17:52

    ‘When one of the journalists who had splashed the retirement story on his front page asked Stoner a question, the Aussie looked him straight in the eye and said “Don’t read what you produce”.’

    One of the many, many reasons I’ve long been a Casey Stoner fan. (well, so long as I saw him on the 250s).

  4. Rich Ambroson, 10 May 2012 17:54

    Love the Doohan references too. He was my favorite in the early/mid 90s when racing against the likes of Rainey, Schwantz, Lawson, Gardner and so on.

    And like Gavin, I totally agree about tech. 100%. Let the riders control the bikes, not software developers.

  5. CH, 10 May 2012 20:14

    What has it come to… Imagine being one of a handful who can even do this, and waking up in the hospital (or not) because of a glitch in the GPS??

    Thank you, very interesting article.

  6. Tony Geran, 11 May 2012 01:28

    Matt

    Relying on satellites to control a Moto GP bike’s throttle? Madness. I don’t think Rossi’s been the same since Stoner’s infamous “ambition exceeded your talent” put down at Jerez last year.

  7. Mat Oxley, 11 May 2012 14:08

    The electronics debate is funny – the riders hate too much electronics just as the fans and Dorna do. The only people who want it are the factories. I believe that eventually three against one will tell. By the way, I was talking nonsense when I blamed Hayden’s problems on GPS. GPS is banned in MotoGP – instead they use different locator technology for their position-sensitive bike tuning. ie, this tech does exactly the same job as GPS.

    Sad that most people don’t get Stoner. When he first turned up he was very young and like a rabbit caught in the headlights, so he didn’t come across so well. Now he’s usually very funny and quite simply astonishing on a bike. Good as Doohan, I reckon

  8. Jonathan Settle, 11 May 2012 20:09

    Funny what people consider to be a tough life aint it! For every racer bitching and moaning there’s millions watching just wishing they had the chance to be part of the circus. No matter what station in life you hold take a look around now and again, you’re doing all right really!
    Really hoping next years CRT type bikes will put GP racing back where it should be, exciting to watch and cheap enough for non factory bikes to spring a surprise or two. Will anyone notice a difference in speed, no, will sponsors and factory’s notice a difference in costs, oh yes.
    Would love to have seen Stoner on a snarling 500, just imagine the moaning, even better, imagine Cal on one, would have been exciting.
    Enjoy the rest of this season, look forward with excitement to next year, its going to be cool!

  9. Jonesracing82, 12 May 2012 00:23

    they should do away with it full stop! MotoGP has almost become unwatchable as they all appear to be on rails! i miss the old days of riders coming out of corners with smoke pouring off the rear tyre as they led on the last lap on thier way to Victory, i actually much prefer Moto2!

  10. R.E.B, 14 May 2012 20:30

    The digital revolution and all of the technology that it has spawned has been a great blessing to the world, except in the realm of motorsport. The unadulterated nature of a purely mechanical racing machine still provides both the greatest driver/rider challenge and spectator spectacle.

  11. Ray T, 16 May 2012 21:25

    I don’t understand the motorcycle manufacturers and this new formula. In the past, GP racing was still two wheels and 1/3 the power of today. The silly tech has developed to deal with the power, yet they push more powerful engines in the formula.
    Meanwhile, the same nonsense is happening with street bikes and guess what, no one is buying them any more. They’ve gone from fun to insane.

    Agostini’s awesome 500cc MV Agusta made a whopping 78hp.

    Tech in aero killed the racing in F1, this tech will kill the interest in motoGP, as the rider is increasingly more just a passenger.

  12. Mario Carneiro Neto, 18 May 2012 18:48

    Doesn’t seem like nonsense now….

Similar content

daytona200-superbike-back

The death of bike racing in the US?

26/02/14

Mat Oxley explains the decline of US Superbikes, which has fed GP racing with top riders for decades

McGuinness

Audio podcast with John McGuinness

30/01/14

20-time Isle of Man TT winner, and new inductee of the Hall of Fame, John McGuinness kicks off our podcasts for 2014

Steve-Parrish

Parrish and McGuinness on tour

13/01/14

Two of bike racing’s biggest characters will be hitting the road in 2014, speaking about their careers

Author

MAT-OXLEY

Mat Oxley

Read Mat's profile and more …