Skip navigation
 
4 September 2012 Opinion 6

Replacing the brilliant Peugeot 205GTI

Yesterday one of the car world’s worst kept secrets finally became official. For the third time, Peugeot is to attempt to replace the 205GTI (below).

Logically enough, the new car will be called the 208GTI and goes on sale in the UK in the Spring with a yet-to-be-disclosed list price rumoured to be around £20,000. For that your 208 will be fitted with the same 1.6-litre turbo motor used in cars as disparate at the Mini Cooper S and Citroen DS4.

opinions  Replacing the brilliant Peugeot 205GTI

In the Peugeot it will have 200bhp, an output seemingly sure to provide interesting acceleration not least because the car will weigh just 1160kg, making it lighter even than the RenaultSport Clio, for many years the most outstanding small sporting hatch on sale. Peugeot talks of a 0-62mph time of under 7sec, but on this evidence that smacks of either Peugeot being conservative or a car with a traction problem.

On top of this Peugeot promises a close ratio six-speed gearbox, and completely new suspension strategies front and rear. This is not just the usual re-tune of springs, bars and dampers, but a widening of the track and the stiffening of the front subframe and rear crossmember to ensure the car more immediately and accurately interprets the instructions of its driver.

It all sounds very encouraging, not least because the standard 208 on which it is based was such a vast improvement on the dismal 207.

But I’m not celebrating yet. When I first drove a 206GTI I couldn’t believe how the fire of the 205 could be so quickly snuffed. And then I drove the 207GTI, which was so dull it didn’t just ignore the memory of the 205GTI so much as raise two fingers to it. I remember the billboard campaign featuring a picture of the 207GTI with a tag line stating “I’m back” with the ‘I’ in the shape of some devilish imp. I’ve not often felt the desire to deface property belonging to another, but the appalling smugness, not to mention utterly misleading nature, of the statement made we want to drive a car into it, preferably a 207GTI.

opinions  Replacing the brilliant Peugeot 205GTI

What worries me about the new car is the accompanying press release. As with any document designed to convey news, it’s a fairly basic requirement that you get the important stuff out there first. This means you can usually tell a lot about how a car manufacturer is seeking to position a car by the way this information is ordered. And the statement put out by Peugeot regarding the car it describes as the one that “regenerates the values of the iconic 205GTI” is fully 14 paragraphs old before it provides any detail about how this car will be powered and what it might be like to drive.

The first sentence relating to the car states “Intended for demanding individuals, 208 GTi owners will benefit from sophisticated choices of the materials and colours employed.” And then you’re into 800 words of LED light technology, gloss black grilles, satin chrome beads (whatever they might be) and overstitched leather hand brake levers.

Only then, right at the very end and for just four short paragraphs does it deign to talk about how the car will be powered and measures taken to improve the driving experience. Hierarchically Peugeot appears to be suggesting that the material with which the handbrake is covered is more important to the customer at which this car is to be aimed than how much fun it is to drive.

Of course we must not read too much into this. It’s just a press release and I’ve long lost count of the number I’ve read that ended up bearing no discernible relation to the cars they sought to describe. Even so, right now it’s all we have to go upon. We’ll know a little more when the 208GTI is unveiled at the Paris Motorshow later this month. But until I’ve actually got in one, driven the door handles off it and felt at least an echo of that incisiveness, communication and enthusiasm that so defined the original, the champagne stays in the refrigerator.

 

Add your comments

6 comments on Replacing the brilliant Peugeot 205GTI

  1. Ben Johnson, 4 September 2012 19:18

    Agreed, but how I would dearly love the 208 GTI (and all Peugeots for that matter) to claim back their ride and handling mastery. I can only conclude that their are still too many non enthusiast bean counter types in high positions within PSA, though that number appears to havr reduced over the last two years.

  2. Simon Lord, 5 September 2012 03:31

    Nice to read a sadly cynical review rather than a re-hashed press release – the spirit of WB lives on, I see.

  3. matt Wills, 5 September 2012 20:48

    I learnt my trade working on 205gti,s and grew up with them as the benchmark hothatch. Since then i,ve owned a string of 205,s and 309 gti,s. The fastest was a 1.6gti (slightly softer rear torsion bars) that I fitted with a 160bhp xu9j4 mi16 motor and 306gti6 6speed gearbox. They are all mega fun to drive the best handling the underated 309gti.
    However times move on, a 205 in the rain on the motorway is no fun at all with the wipers lifting off the screen at 70mph,they need copious amounts of tlc to keep them it good shape,rattle free and i,ve not seen one with a factory sliding sunroof that didnt leak.
    Peugeots have lost there flare for design I hope they can get it back with the 208.

  4. Lee Williams, 8 September 2012 00:18

    £20K and a turbo? How’s that like a 205 GTI? If you want the 205 GTI experience in new metal, what’s wrong with a Twingo Cup? I had one and it was amazing. I’d recommend one before the square wheel society get us even more humps, 20mph zones and, eventually, a need for a red flag man. Cars are getting bigger and it is a real problem. I’m wondering if that latest Golf GTI is a similar size to the BMC land crab….

  5. scott lewis, 11 November 2012 22:22

    Im Hoping that this will work out. And will be close to the 205 GTI
    peugeot needs another ass kicking car.

  6. asterix, 29 December 2012 20:52

    I’m sad to be pessimistic, but I don’t believe in 208 Gti. They promise it to be comfortable. It weighs at least 270 kg more than the 205 Gti 1.9. The THP engine from RCZ is like a rubber band, nothing to offer immediate response to correct a snappy over-steer from the 205…err 208 with computerized handling and stabilization control. 208 will be the 205 Britney, overweight, no talent, and only a former glory to sell with.

Similar content

8712786-1-2

The rising price of Aston Martins

04/06/13

Am I alone in still goggling at some of the prices paid for Aston Martins at Bonhams’ sale at Newport …

Garching_Bundesautobahn_9

Autobahns to stay without limits

21/05/13

Spare a moment if you will for one Sigmar Gabriel, chairman of the German Social Democratic Party who took the …

GTIs

Peugeot 205GTI vs 208GTI

14/05/13

I’ll admit that, thanks to the presence of a Peugeot 205GTI in my shed, I was more torn than usual …

Author

MB220S_FHR_018

Andrew Frankel

Read Andrew's profile and more …