Can full-time stewards really end F1's penalty lottery?

F1
November 20, 2026

The FIA hopes full-time stewards will bring greater consistency to F1's penalty decisions from 2027, but a permanent panel could create new challenges of its own

BIGGIN HILL, ENGLAND - OCTOBER 20: A general view of the FIA Remote Operations Centre during the Opening of the FIA Remote Operations Centre at Formula One Management on October 20, 2026 in Biggin Hill, England

The FIA hopes that introducing full-time stewards from 2027 will help address one of Formula 1's longest-running complaints

Getty Images

November 20, 2026

Formula 1‘s penalty lottery has been a source of frustration for drivers, teams and fans for years, as similar incidents have produced vastly different outcomes, while the rotating panel of stewards has repeatedly come under scrutiny for its interpretation of the rules.

George Russell was among those calling for change in 2024, arguing that Formula 1 needed permanent, professionally employed stewards to bring greater consistency to its decision-making.

“I do think we’re at a point now in this sport that we do need a full-time professional steward in where they earn a real salary,” the Mercedes driver said.

“They’re not effectively volunteers and I do think within the pool of stewards we’ve got now, they are definitely up to standard. So it’s not saying anything bad about the current stewards, it’s just saying I feel we should be having system stewarding a week in, week out.”

Two years later, the FIA has finally agreed.

The ruling body announced on Thursday that from 2027, it will begin recruiting full-time officials, with the aim of establishing a department of 12-15 stewards.

But while the move addresses one of the sport’s most persistent complaints, will it really put an end to F1’s penalty lottery?

The debate over permanent stewards gathered momentum during the contentious 2024 United States and Mexico Grands Prix, when several incidents involving Max Verstappen and Lando Norris reignited arguments about how racing rules should be interpreted.

Russell called for permanent, professionally employed stewards in 2024, arguing that greater continuity could help bring consistency to Formula 1's penalty decisions

Russell called for permanent, professionally employed stewards in 2024, arguing that greater continuity could help bring consistency to Formula 1’s penalty decisions

Mercedes

At the United States GP, Norris received a five-second penalty for overtaking off-track, while Verstappen faced two 10-second penalties in Mexico for very similar track-limit and forcing incidents.

Russell, who is a director of the Grand Prix Drivers’ Association, suggested that employing a permanent group of professional stewards would help drivers understand what was expected of them.

“If you were to have the same stewards week in, week out, the consistency will be better because they’re interpreting things in the same manner and the drivers understand exactly what they expect in a given circumstance,” he said.

The Mercedes driver was careful not to criticise the existing pool of officials, insisting that they were up to standard.

His argument was instead that F1 had reached a point where the importance of its decisions justified employing stewards on full-time salaries rather than relying on officials who work in a part-time capacity.

Not everyone was convinced that this would be a straightforward solution. Some questioned whether any steward could realistically manage a 24-race calendar, while also pointing out that even two officials could have different opinions about the same incident.

That is an important distinction.

The problem is not necessarily that individual stewards lack the experience or ability to make good decisions, but that racing incidents are inherently subjective, and even experienced officials will sometimes disagree about where responsibility lies.

The FIA’s announcement is therefore an attempt to address the issue through greater continuity rather than simply changing the people responsible for making decisions.

Controversial battles between Verstappen and Norris in 2024 reignited the debate

Controversial battles between Verstappen and Norris in 2024 reignited the debate

Grand Prix Photo

The introduction will be phased, with a small number of full-time stewards recruited during 2027 before the department expands in the following years.

Existing part-time officials will continue to contribute, while a driver steward will remain involved at every event.

The FIA also intends for the new department to work beyond race weekends, reviewing previous decisions, identifying recurring problems and highlighting areas where sporting regulations or racing guidelines might need clarification. It will also help train and mentor future officials.

That could ultimately prove more important than simply having the same people overseeing incidents from one grand prix to the next.

One of the biggest difficulties with F1’s racing guidelines is that they attempt to provide a framework for situations that are rarely identical.

Whether a driver has left sufficient space, gained an advantage or been predominantly responsible for an incident can depend on several factors that are difficult to capture in a set of written instructions.

Having a permanent group of stewards should make it easier to establish a shared understanding of those guidelines, but it will not automatically remove the subjectivity involved in interpreting them.

Nor does consistency necessarily guarantee correctness.

Permanent officials could bring greater continuity to F1's decision-making

Permanent officials could bring greater continuity to F1’s decision-making

A permanent group of officials could become more consistent in its interpretation of the rules without necessarily producing decisions that satisfy everyone. If the guidelines themselves are ambiguous, having the same people applying them will only go so far.

There is also the question of whether a relatively small group of permanent officials will be able to maintain the independence and fresh perspective that the existing rotating system provides.

The continued involvement of part-time stewards and former drivers should help preserve that balance, although it also means the new structure will not completely eliminate changes in personnel between events.

There is another potential drawback to having a permanent group of stewards: the risk that their decisions could increasingly be perceived as biased.

Related article

F1 has a passionate and often polarised fanbase, and controversial penalties are frequently interpreted through the lens of which driver benefits or suffers.

A series of decisions going against a particular driver could quickly fuel accusations that certain competitors are being treated unfairly, even if there is no evidence of any favouritism.

The rotating system at least provides some distance between individual officials and the drivers they are judging. A permanent group would inevitably become more familiar to teams, drivers and fans, but that familiarity could also make its members more prominent targets whenever a contentious decision is made.

The FIA will therefore need to ensure that its new structure is not only consistent and transparent, but also seen to be independent.

The FIA is nevertheless moving in the direction Russell was advocating two years ago. The creation of its new Remote Operations Centre at Biggin Hill and the wider investment in its officials department are part of the same effort to professionalise the way the sport is governed.

It is a welcome development, particularly given how much influence stewarding decisions can have on races and championships, but the real test will not be whether F1 has the same officials at every grand prix. It will be whether drivers can race with a clearer understanding of what is permitted, and whether comparable incidents finally produce comparable outcomes.

Pablo Elizalde

Pablo has been covering motorsport (mainly F1 and MotoGP) as an editor and writer for over 20 years, having worked for Autosport and Motorsport.com before joining Motor Sport Magazine.

More from Pablo