THE CITROEN CONTROVERSY
Perhaps Mr. McGrath has been unlucky with the particular Citroen he has been running—just as I have, perhaps, been lucky. Moreover, whereas Mr. MeGrath’s car was a 1952 Light Fifteen, mine was a pre-(very) war 12.8-h.p. Nevertheless, despite the short. comings naturally Attendant on a car of such age, I found the Citroen far and away the hest thing I had ever had my hands on, judged as a family-cum-sporta model. First, the. cornering and roadholding : despite lack of the rack and pinion found on present models, this car could be steered into really-sharp earners at speeds right up to its maximum, sitting down on the road as steady as a rock and under perfect control. Second, tyres : I experienced rather excessive front tyrewear to begin with. but I believe this was because I made maximum use of the car’s cornering ability : I was so thrilled by its potentialities that I treated it cruelly, front sheer exuberance. When I settled down to more normal methods—but still as a matter of course taking liberties that would have been impossible on most Cars-1 found the covers showing hardly any wear. Third, acceleration : now, what exactly does Mr. McGrath mean, ” non-existent ” ? The Light Fifteen is not a powerful car, and the 12.8 even less so, but light weight and intelligent gearing produce road-test figures little inferior to the A70, and this is confirmed by experience. I found my own 12.8 a match for most machinery up to 2 litres if I really let the revs, soar remember it’s a five-seater family car, not a Le Mans Replica! That
is another of its charms—it is comfortable, roomy without being big, well equipped, in fact the enthusiast’s complete answer to a critical wife! Mr. McGrath mentions gear-change, and I agree this is not beyond reproach when going from second to bottom at any speed—but how often does one need, or wish, to go from second to bottom at 10+ m.p.h. ? In other respects the gear-change is good. particularly from second to top when really dicing.
For my money, the Citroen is No. 1 choice : beautiful to handle. solid, fully adequate in performance, intelligently designed, roomy, a car of real character. Finally, and very important, the question of actual road performance—as distinct from -figures on paper. On a short sprint, along a clear road, the A70 would probably win easily, hut on a cross-country journey of any length I’d bads the Citroen every time. on cornering ability alone. Moreover, in countrieS where fiat-out driving is possible for long periods, which car would stand up best to a sustained 75 m.p.h., the Citroen, at its maximum, or the A70, capable of seeing a true 80 ?
Coventry. ” THAerrioN AVANT.”
Editorial, October 2002
Paul Fearnley, Editor Now I'm not going to sit here and tell you that the just-gone Goodwood Revival was bigger and better than ever before. It was merely as good as…
Vintage Postbag, January 1959
Sir, After the first World War a flood of cheap cyclecars appeared on the market in response to a widespread demand for economical motoring. This was particularly so in France, where a great…
Racing car show
Quick change The British Racing and Sports Car Club has done it again! Last year, despite overwhelming odds from one of the worst winters ever seen in this country, the…