2024 Renault Scenic review: At last — a fun electric car
In this spot last month I reviewed the new electric Peugeot 3008 and now, hot on its heels, comes its deadliest rival, domestic or otherwise. As regulars will be aware,…
I wonder how many thousands of key strokes I have expended being critical of fast Audis in print over the years? Thousands? Millions more likely. I reckon it started a little over 30 years ago, when the company replaced the original quattro with the S2 Coupé. And I didn’t need to review that to know it wasn’t very good: my father bought one to replace a 911 so I already knew.
Then came the first of the RS Audis, the 1994 RS2. Gorgeous to look at, sit in and listen to. But the drive failed to live up to such promise. And that was just the start. Of all those that followed, the only fast family Audi I recall with any genuine affection was the ‘B7’ RS4 Avant built between 2006-08 thanks to the fabulous pairing of its screaming naturally aspirated V8 motor and a Getrag six-speed manual gearbox.
But now, finally, there’s another. I booked the RS6 Performance not because I suspected it might buck the trend of the last 30 years, but simply because I’d not yet made its acquaintance and thought I probably should. The ‘Performance’ in its title suggests it’s a variant from standard but in fact it’s now the only kind of RS6 you can buy. What you can do is opt for coil rather than air springs, ceramic brakes and lightweight wheels with soft-compound tyres to create a kind of RS6 Performance-Performance, but the car I drove was standard and seemed none the worse.
What all Performance RS6s get compared to the now defunct simple RS6 is a 30bhp power boost thanks to bigger turbos for its 4-litre V8, a similar upgrade in torque and, more interesting to me, four-wheel steering and a torque vectoring rear differential.
It’s a great-looking car but, then again, fast Audi estates have never struggled to hoover up attention from street corners. But I particularly like the fact that Audi’s super-clean, almost industrial design has been allowed to grow a few sculptural curves. The result is more characterful, purposeful yet no less easily discernible as an Audi.
It’s fast, ridiculously so in fact, but you knew that already. But even by big V8 standards, it’s tuneful too: Audi has stripped out a load of sound-deadening material, not really to save weight (8kg doesn’t go far in a 2090kg car) nor even really to make it any louder; instead it’s been taken from areas muffling the quality of its sound as if to reinforce exactly what we’ll be missing when its electric replacement comes along.
“It’s a family car and fine driving machine all wrapped into one”
But really that’s all background. What feels so different about this fast family Audi is, well, its feel. Within about a minute I knew I was going to enjoy this more than almost any of its kind that had come before. Actually it was probably less than that. Do this job for long enough and you don’t need more than a few rotations of the tyres to sense a stiff structure off which have been hung well-located wheels subjected to iron-fisted control from its springs and dampers. In that moment you know it’s been set up by people who think like you, and the rest all stems from that.
For a start it rides brilliantly, this ultra-sporting estate easily outpointing many previous generations of long-wheelbase A8 limousines. And that was a pleasant surprise, but what made me want to write this was the way it took me from place to place. It is a point-and-squirt machine no longer. The greatest shame of most RS Audis I’ve driven is that they turn corners into the boring bits, frustrating periods of time that have to be endured before the fun can begin again at the start of the next straight when you can once more unleash whichever fabulous powertrain lurks ahead of you. That imbalance has now been entirely addressed.
If you head west out of the pretty Welsh town of Crickhowell and take the A479 towards Builth Wells, you’ll find a road a car like this should hate. It’s quite narrow in places, with corners that tend to come at you in combinations, with the odd tightening radius. It’s a good road, but not one of the Welsh greats, not least because vast trucks tend to come thundering around corners using more than their fair share of space. Here you need a car whose extremities you can judge by instinct, one that, when asked to suddenly tighten its line by a few degrees, does so both instantly and accurately. A car that will not just ride the bumps well, but the crests and dips too, which is a very different skill set.
This Audi – repeat, Audi – does it all. Agile is the wrong word for it because that summons up thoughts of Porsche Caymans and so on, which would be preposterous. But ‘deft’ is very definitely the right word, and I doubt I’ve ever used it in the context of a big Audi estate before.
And suddenly a kind of car that for so long has seemed a disconnected accumulation of unrelated talents – great engine, looks, sound – became one cohesive whole, a car with no serious shortcomings save its price and eye-watering fuel consumption. In short the family car and fine driving machine all wrapped into one that so many of its forebears promised but ultimately failed to be. More cars tuned with this philosophy in more accessible areas of the model range transform for the better the way we look at fast Audis in future.
In this spot last month I reviewed the new electric Peugeot 3008 and now, hot on its heels, comes its deadliest rival, domestic or otherwise. As regulars will be aware,…
If you look at the Land Rover LRX concept from 2008 and this Range Rover Evoque, you’ll be left in no doubt what a debt the latter owes the former.…
Back in 2011 Rolls-Royce announced that it had made an electric car. Just one, mind, to canvass the views of current and prospective customers and those of a small number…
I’m always quite nervous when it comes writing about industry stories, largely because I think they are of far greater interest to nosey hacks like me who know some of…
Five years ago, missing the Geneva Motor Show was virtually unthinkable for any major car manufacturer. This year’s list of exhibitors is embarrassingly full of largely unknown brands. Andrew Frankel looks behind the staggering demise
Searching for the pinnacle of motor car production, Andrew Frankel winds the clock back 14 years to ‘peak car’. We just didn’t know this was as good as it was ever going to get
The electric revolution is set to continue in 2024, with a new MG roadster, Porsche’s battery-powered Macan, and Renault’s fun-focused 5. But the combustion engine will continue roaring too, says Andrew Frankel, thanks to supercar makers and a rare BMW M5 Touring
It was a year dominated by new electric car launches — too many of which were lacklustre. But among the cars that over-promised and underdelivered, Andrew Frankel found some gems — both battery- and petrol-powered
This is the most important new Volvo in years. Decades possibly. At least to Volvo. The EX30 is Volvo’s first crack at the compact crossover EV market, a sector that…
The car industry is ploughing billions of pounds into electric cars but sales declined among private buyers in September. Andrew Frankel puts his finger on the problem
Remember Jaguar? Time was when it was the pride of the nation, and even in more recent times it’s made some fine cars among a few frankly undeniable clunkers. When…
I try hard, as hard as I can, not to pre-judge cars. Let them stand or fall on their own merits rather than your preconceptions of how they’re likely to…