Does Imola deserve its F1 slot? Our verdict on its most recent races

F1

Since Imola returned to the F1 calendar in 2020 it has served up a mixed bag of grands prix. With its future in doubt, we give our verdict on each of the races this decade

Lewis Hamilton (Mercedes) and Max Verstappen (Red Bull-Honda) at the start of the 2021 Emilia Romagna Grand Prix in Imola

Hamilton and Verstappen starred in the 2021 race

This weekend’s Emilia Romagna Grand Prix could be the last Formula 1 race at Imola for now unless organisers manage to secure a new contract, either on a yearly basis or as part of the championship’s planned rotating calendar.

In the words of F1 CEO Stefano Domenicali, “It will be increasingly difficult to have two races in the same country because interest in F1 is growing”.

With Monza having a contract to host the Italian Grand Prix until at least 2031, the future of Imola beyond this weekend is very much up in the air.

The Autodromo Enzo e Dino Ferrari had a solid place on the calendar from 1986 to 2006, but was dropped for 2007 and didn’t return until F1 needed to find alternatives to the cancelled races during the Covid-19 pandemic.

So Imola will host its fifth grand prix since returning to the calendar this weekend, the 2023 event cancelled as a result of the floods in the Emilia Romagna area.

Related article

As one of the classic circuits left on the calendar, Imola has plenty of supporters that would like to stay where it is.

However, since its return to the schedule, the track has failed to produce spectacular races in a consistent manner, so there are also fans who wouldn’t miss it should it disappear after this season.

Both of the statements above are not exclusive to Imola, as there are plenty of circuits that divide the opinion of fans, and as the F1 calendar continues to expand beyond Europe, more classic tracks are likely to face an uncertain future.

Has Imola’s brief return justified a longer stay on the calendar? Here’s a recap of the recent races.

 

2020

Lewis Hamilton (Mercedes) in parc ferme after the 2020 Emilia Romagna Grand Prix

Hamilton won Imola’s first race after its return

Grand Prix Photo

One could argue any sort of race was a good race in 2020, when it looked like the pandemic could have led to the cancellation of the entire season.

As F1 rushed to find events that could replace all the cancelled flyaways, Imola found its way back onto a 17-race calendar. It was a rare addition to a schedule that has almost exclusively expanded to new venues in recent times, but one that was welcomed by many fans of classic circuits.

The race was decent enough, although it highlighted the difficulty the current generation of cars have with overtaking on layouts such as Imola’s.

Valtteri Bottas had started from pole position ahead of Mercedes team-mate Lewis Hamilton, who lost second place at the start to Max Verstappen.

The order at the top remained unchanged despite Bottas having floor damage as a result of debris on track. When the pitstops began around lap 20, Bottas was the first to pit as the leader of the race.

Hamilton extended his first stint by several laps and, thanks to the damage to Bottas’s car, the Briton was able to keep the gap steady. Then, on lap 30, a virtual safety car allowed Hamilton to make his pitstop and return to the track in the lead, a position he managed to retain without too much trouble until the end of the race.

A late safety car made things more intriguing for a moment, but Hamilton’s pace was superior and allowed him to win by nearly six seconds from Bottas and Renault’s Daniel Ricciardo, who had benefitted from Verstappen’s retirement.

Ultimately, the race was rather straightforward, and strategy played a bigger role than on-track action.

Verdict: Not fantastic, but not worse than other races elsewhere

2020 Emilia Romagna GP race report

 

2021

Lando Norris (McLaren-Mercedes) and Max Verstappen (Red Bull-Honda) on the podium after the 2021 Emilia Romagna Grand Prix

The 2021 race remains the best one so far

The 2021 grand prix remains the highlight of Imola’s short stint on the current F1 calendar: It was a race full of drama and twists, even though a familiar winner emerged in Verstappen.

Heavy rain before the race created treacherous conditions, so all drivers opted for wet-weather tyres. Verstappen made a lightning start from third on the grid, overtaking pole-sitter Hamilton at the first corner with an aggressive move and seizing the lead as the Mercedes driver bounced on the speed bumps after going off track.

It only took two laps before the first safety car was deployed, when Nicolas Latifi crashed his Williams after contact with Nikita Mazepin‘s Haas at Acque Minerali.

Related article

As the track started to dry up, Verstappen pitted from the lead on lap 27 to put on slicks. Hamilton, seeking to use an overcut to overtake Verstappen, looked to be neck-and-neck with his rival when he came into the pits the next lap, but a comparatively slow stop dropped him back behind the Red Bull.

Verstappen had more pace and managed to open a three-second gap even in dry conditions. Disaster struck for Hamilton as he slid into the gravel at Tosa, driving straight into the wall as he tried to rejoin the race. He managed to return to the track with a damaged wing and many positions down the order.

But then as Hamilton rejoined the race, another safety car was deployed after a massive crash between Bottas and George Russell triggered by the Williams driver hitting the grass and sliding into the Mercedes. The amount of debris left on track meant the race was red-flagged.

At the restart, Verstappen kept things under control, this time without the pressure of Hamilton, who was down in eighth after his accident.

From there, the Mercedes driver completed a sensational recovery to second by lap 60 of 63, by which time Verstappen was over 20 seconds in front, the Red Bull driver cruising to victory.

Verdict: A great race, but it wasn’t exclusively down to the circuit.

2021 Emilia Romagna GP race report

 

2022

Max Verstappen (Red Bull-Honda) in front of Lando Norris (McLaren-Mercedes) in the sprint race before the 2022 Emilia Romagna Grand Prix

Verstappen dominated the entire weekend in 2022

Grand Prix Photo

The first sprint race weekend at Imola was a show of strength by Verstappen, who fully dominated the weekend from start to finish.

The Red Bull driver started the sprint race from pole but lost out to Charles Leclerc, who managed to keep the Dutchman at buy for 20 of the 21 laps before a DRS pass secured Verstappen the lead and, with it, the first victory of the weekend.

It was a tense race with a great overtake by Verstappen, who would have probably taken an easy win had he made a better start. And that’s what he did on Sunday.

Like in the previous year, it was a wet start following some pre-race rain, with the entire field starting on intermediate tyres. Unlike the previous year, however, Verstappen had no real opposition right from the start, as he quickly opened a gap to team-mate Sergio Perez as the tried dried up.

The switch to slicks started around 20, when Verstappen had close to a 10-second lead over Perez, a gap that continued to grow as the race progressed.

By the chequered flag, Verstappen had a 16-second advantage as he completed his second career grand slam, having led every lap and also securing the fastest lap.

Verdict: Too much Verstappen domination to produce a good race

2022 Emilia Romagna GP race report

 

2024

Max Verstappen (Red Bull-Honda) celebrates after the 2024 Emilia Romagna Grand Prix

Verstappen took his third Imola win in 2024

Grand Prix Photo

Sadly for Imola, the latest race highlighted the shortcomings of the circuit for the current crop of F1 cars.

After being forced to skip the 2023 event because of the flooding in the era, F1’s return to the track was not a big success as it produced a processional race won again by Verstappen.

The Red Bull driver started from pole position once again and was quick to build a comfortable gap over Lando Norris. From there, it was a very straightforward – read boring – race until the final 15 laps, when Norris began to close in on Verstappen.

It was an exciting finish as the McLaren driver reduced a six-second gap to almost nothing by the start of the final lap, but even that didn’t help disguise the fact that the race had been extremely boring for some 50 laps.

The decision to have a shorter DRS zone didn’t help, and overtaking was scarce once more.

Verdict: Unwatchable until the final 15 laps

2024 Emilia Romagna GP analysis