Brush v. camera

Browse pages
Current page

1

Current page

2

Current page

3

Current page

4

Current page

5

Current page

6

Current page

7

Current page

8

Current page

9

Current page

10

Current page

11

Current page

12

Current page

13

Current page

14

Current page

15

Current page

16

Current page

17

Current page

18

Current page

19

Current page

20

Current page

21

Current page

22

Current page

23

Current page

24

Current page

25

Current page

26

Current page

27

Current page

28

Current page

29

Current page

30

Current page

31

Current page

32

Current page

33

Current page

34

Current page

35

Current page

36

Current page

37

Current page

38

Current page

39

Current page

40

Current page

41

Current page

42

Current page

43

Current page

44

Current page

45

Current page

46

Current page

47

Current page

48

Current page

49

Current page

50

Current page

51

Current page

52

Current page

53

Current page

54

Current page

55

Current page

56

Current page

57

Current page

58

Current page

59

Current page

60

Current page

61

Current page

62

Current page

63

Current page

64

Current page

65

Current page

66

Current page

67

Current page

68

Current page

69

Current page

70

Current page

71

Current page

72

Current page

73

Current page

74

Current page

75

Current page

76

Current page

77

Current page

78

Current page

79

Current page

80

Current page

81

Current page

82

Current page

83

Current page

84

Current page

85

Current page

86

Current page

87

Current page

88

Current page

89

Current page

90

Current page

91

Current page

92

Current page

93

Current page

94

Current page

95

Current page

96

Current page

97

Current page

98

Current page

99

Current page

100

Current page

101

Current page

102

Current page

103

Current page

104

Current page

105

Current page

106

Current page

107

Current page

108

Current page

109

Current page

110

Current page

111

Current page

112

Current page

113

Current page

114

Current page

115

Current page

116

Current page

117

Current page

118

Current page

119

Current page

120

Current page

121

Current page

122

Current page

123

Sir,
As a second-year student in photography, I must write in protest at Mr. Hellings’ remarks about photography.

Firstly both he and you appear to hold the antiquated point of view that the only artist is one who paints. You should not confuse media with use of media—cannot an artist also use light-sensitive materials as well as pigment?

Secondly, Mr. Hellings’ letter shows his basic misunderstandings of the optical laws. Where photography using “long” lenses is concerned it is certainly not the camera that causes the “flattened” perspective; it is the distance between the camera and subject that does this. The eye’s definition (and focal length of around 50 mm.) is not adequate to discern detail far off—the telephoto camera merely takes a small section of a scene and enlarges it sufficiently for us to see this detail. This law also applies to “wide angle” photography where the camera has the ability to “take in” more than the eye. The camera is a mechanical “eye”, Mr. Hellings, it cannot create fiction from fact—that is the preserve of the painter! Every photograph must obey the laws of optics, since a camera merely records what is there.

Thirdly, if Mr. Hellings considers it lying to merely enlarge detail, does he not consider it lying to add “a wet track, spray, headlights”, etc., when they were never there! That, I suppose, he would call “artistic licence”! Whilst on detail, if Mr. Hellings could paint 50 per cent. of the detail obtainable on a 10 X 8 photograph, I would be astounded.

Fourthly, “atmosphere” in a picture is dependent on the emotional response of the viewer, it is not rateable in terms of detail and composition.

Finally, the camera has the sole ability to capture in a flash that moment of truth—the elation of the winner, the dejection of a driver who lost the race on the last corner. It is this truth which makes photography, and sadly the lack of the same which brings down so many photographs published in your magazine which, otherwise, I consider to be the best.

Martin Roberts.
Derby.

[The very points I was trying to make! Unfortunately, although cameras should not lie, very strange things can be done to negatives, prints and colour transparencies by unscrupulous “toucher-uppers”. But then, they are artists of a kind, not photographers.—This is but one letter received in defence of the camera versus the brush.—Ed.]