Why damaged racing memorabilia can be worth more to collectors

In the world of collectibles, especially true rarities, imperfection can often turn out to be, well, perfect. Let’s talk damaged goods and why they can often be better than picture-perfect pieces.

Collectibles are a record of time and often the greatest value comes from linking a piece to a specific place or event. Damage can often be a record of a specific moment and knowing when something picked up a chip, dent or scratch can be a key identifier for valuation.

Damage can also enhance an item’s value through its story. Take, for example, the tale of Niki Lauda’s AGV crash helmet, above, which he was wearing during that horrific accident in 1976. The damaged helmet was recovered and put on display at an Italian motor show in the late 1980s, where it was stolen. It was missing for almost 40 years before it cropped up at an auction in Miami in 2024 with a guide price of £46,000. AGV found out and blocked the sale so we’ll never know its true value, but to somebody that’s worth a fortune.

We once had a case when somebody offered us what looked to be an ordinary ‘Corker’ classic racing helmet that had been found in storage. We liked it so did our usual due diligence, spoke to the manufacturer and we identified a stone chip on the front that tied it to a specific driver at a specific grand prix, which he won… all verified by period photos and manufacturer accounts and suddenly the value soars!

Obviously, there are cases when damage totally undoes value, for example when Lando Norris accidentally smashed Max Verstappen’s porcelain Hungarian Grand Prix trophy in 2023 – I doubt the fragments are worth much on their own and it likely ended up in the bin anyway.

So next time you see that old dented trophy, frayed race suit or pitted helmet, it may well be worth your while taking a second look.

Andrew Francis is director at The Signature Store. thesignaturestore.co.uk

Godzilla X Haas Hoodie

Haas F1 Team isn’t that well known for its merch, but this new collab with Godzilla – the reptilian giant of movie fame – could change that. Our pick is this hoodie, with hybrid logo on the front and full ‘King of the Monsters’ on the back, above, towering over a city skyline.
£72, haasf1.shop

Babolat X Lamborghini Padel Racquet

Why is this a thing? Well, padel is all the rage. As are Lamborghinis. So maybe this partnership makes a little sense. This racquet features a 3K carbon frame and is both lightweight and aerodynamic.
£519.99, tennisnuts.com

Verstappen Racing X Mitchell & Ness Karting Jacket

If you’re after some Max-flavoured items that aren’t doused in Red Bull, check out this tie-up with Mitchell & Ness, which has created a range based on his karting days. The bomber jacket is gloriously retro.
£145, mitchellandness.co.uk

Skechers Garage

Where were these when we were kids? In fact, where are they now in adult sizes? Skechers’ latest kids’ shoes feature a heel-based garage for your motoring miniatures, allowing play anywhere. Available in two colourways, children’s size 9.5-2.
£55, skechers.com