Can Williams rookie Colapinto really do a better job than Sargeant?

F1

With the beleaguered Logan Sargeant finally out at Williams, now the Grove team is replacing him with a rookie for the rest of F1 2024 – is Franco Colapinto up to the challenge?

Franco Colapinto Williams 2024 barhain GP

Colapinto will replace Sargeant for the remainder of 2024 – can he keep his head above water?

Grand Prix Photo

Late on Tuesday Williams announced that Logan Sargeant has been booted out of the team and will be replaced by junior driver Franco Colapinto for the balance of the 2024 Formula 1 season.

Sargeant’s tenuous position had been no secret, and his huge crash in FP3 in Zandvoort with a car carrying a package of brand-new parts was clearly the final straw.

This is a team fighting for every point, and which is currently lying ninth in the world championship, nine points shy of Alpine. It has nine races left in which to score and move up.

The surprise perhaps was that team boss James Vowles opted for a guy whose F1 mileage to date is confined to half a day in the Abu Dhabi rookie test last year, and an FP1 session in Sargeant’s car at Silverstone in July.

Logan Sargeant Williams 2024 Dutch GP Zandvoort

Sargeant was shown the door after a litany of errors

Grand Prix Photo

Given only a few days before he jumps in the FW46 again at Monza on Friday, Colapinto faces a massive challenge this weekend. The first outing will be more about getting him up to speed for the later races in the season.

This was not a decision taken lightly, especially on the marketing and PR side, as it removes Sargeant for the Austin and Las Vegas races. However, clearly Vowles and his Dorilton colleagues believe that the 21-year-old can do a better job over the balance of the season.

Sargeant was no mug. He was an FIA F3 and F2 race winner, and he did enough to convince then Williams boss Jost Capito that he was worthy of a race seat in 2023, despite running just a single season in F2.

By the time he started Vowles was in charge. The problem the American faced over his tenure in the team was that he never came close to keeping Alex Albon on his toes. There were occasional solid qualifying and race performances, but rarely any sign of real spark, or the forward progress that Vowles wanted to see. A series of expensive crashes only made things worse.

“Sargeant used up the last of his jokers in the Zandvoort crash”

It became clear many months ago that he wouldn’t be retained for 2025, as Vowles turned his focus to finding a replacement on Albon’s level, and successfully convinced Carlos Sainz to come on board.

Sargeant used up the last of his jokers in the Zandvoort crash, and by Sunday the paddock was awash with rumours about a potential replacement. Helmut Marko confirmed to Motor Sport that a loan of Liam Lawson had been discussed, but he also hinted that Red Bull has its own plans for the Kiwi within this season, which is another story…

Toto Wolff ruled out the possibility of Kimi Antonelli being fast-tracked into a Williams seat as training for next year, and instead touted his reserve driver Mick Schumacher – a man whose crash-strewn career at Haas mirrored that of Sargeant at Williams.

In the end Vowles and Dorilton opted for their own man in Colapinto, despite his limited F1 mileage and the fact that these nine races are leading nowhere in terms of his Willams future – Albon and Sainz are committed for the long-term.

Franco Colapinto Le Mans 2021

Colaptino at Le Mans in 2021, where he finished seventh in the LMP2 class – the Argentinian has experience in bringing cars home safely

Getty Images

Colapinto has a solid if relatively modest CV. He was third in Formula Renault Eurocup in 2020, sixth in FRECA in 2021, and fourth in FIA F3 in 2023, after a collarbone injury compromised the end of his season.

In F2 this year he won the Imola sprint and was second in the Spanish and Austria features, and he currently lies sixth in the championship. He’s heading into his F1 debut with less F2 experience than Sargeant had amassed, given that there are four weekends to go.

However, what he does have in his pocket is some useful sports car mileage, having raced in LMP2 while still a teenager – indeed he contested the 2021 Le Mans 24 Hours alongside future F1 driver Nyck de Vries.

Related article

Vowles says Williams has ‘to let go of F1 past’ to succeed
F1

Vowles says Williams has 'to let go of F1 past' to succeed

Williams is one of F1's most successful teams, but hasn't won in a long time – its principal James Vowles explains why the approach of Frank and Patrick won't work in the modern age, and how he's doing things differently

By James Elson

Vowles clearly sees something in the data and the smiley, upbeat personality that has convinced him that Colapinto can do a better job than Sargeant over the balance of this season.

He will be a breath of fresh air for the Williams camp. At Interlagos last year he was embedded in the team as part of his preparations for the Abu Dhabi rookie test, and his enthusiasm and excitement at just being part of the F1 environment was clear to see – there was no sign of the sense of entitlement that some youngsters display when they reach the top level.

“Driving the F1 car on the Tuesday after the race in Abu Dhabi, it’s going to be a very unique moment for me, very special,” he said that weekend. “Since I started racing in go-karts when I was 10 years old, my dream was one day to be able to drive an F1 car.

“And to already have that in sight and being able to have that first test, those first few laps, is something unbelievable. I was not really thinking about it, or even expecting it, when the year started.

“Williams have been so helpful this year, to be working with them so much. It’s been an amazing opportunity to be with such an historic team, with such a big legacy in motorsport, in F1. It’s one of the things that I dreamed of since I was a kid.

“And they have been super helpful, not only driving-wise, but also on the personal aspect they have been really supportive. And I’m just very proud to be part of this team. I hope to continue this journey many more years together.”

2 Franco Colapinto (Williams-Mercedes) in the pits during 2023 Young Driver : Post Season Test on November 28 at Yas Marina circuit in Abu Dhabi

Colapinto driving in the 2023 Abu Dhabi young driver test

Getty Images

That journey hasn’t been so easy. In his mid-teens Colapinto was dispatched to Italy to further his career, and thus had to do some growing up far from home.

“Argentina is my country since I was a little kid, I lived there until I was 14 years old,” he said in Brazil. “But it almost feels like I’m still living there, all my family are still in Argentina, in Buenos Aires.

“I left when I was 14 years old only to Italy, I didn’t know Italian, I needed to wash my clothes, I started to cook for myself. These are the sacrifices that someone makes to achieve what you want in sport.

“And of course, it’s been hard, I’ve been through many challenges. And now I’m just enjoying the moment, enjoying being at the top of motor sport, that is a sport that I love.

Gaston Mazzacane Prost 2001

Gaston Mazzacane was the last Argentinian to race in F1, for Prost 2001

Getty Images

“Then suddenly you realise I’m in F1, and it’s something insane that two years ago, I was looking at on TV, thinking it was super far away.”

It’s not been straightforward for Colapinto in terms of securing sponsorship in his home country – there’s a reason why Argentina hasn’t had an F1 driver since Gaston Mazzacane at Prost 23 years ago.

“It’s been really hard to find the budget,” he explained. “It’s very difficult for a South American. And with the sponsors, with the economic situation of Argentina, unfortunately, it’s very difficult for my home companies to support me, because the economic situation is really bad there.

Related article

“And I’m glad that I have so much support from everyone that can do it, from everyone that can put a little bit of sand on the table, they are doing it.

“The fans have done a big thing in Argentina. Actually, many companies have called me because of them, because of the massive support that I’ve received. And they are a big part of what is happening right now.

“I think if you see any other driver, or any European driver, he’s not even getting 25 times less the support that I’m getting from my home country. So it’s something amazing to have, and I’m just very grateful to have that in my background. It’s pushing me and motivating me to continue pushing forward.”

He was full of praise for the Williams Driver Academy programme, which included sim running: “The help has been massive. This year, I grew so much as a driver, with the help of the Academy, with the help of Williams, being in the simulator and working with F1 engineers, working as well with Logan and Alex, it’s been an immense help.

“And I grew so much not only driving-wise, but also on the personal aspect, to be more professional and stuff like that. I just keep learning stuff every day after day that I’m here.”

Franco Colapinto Williams 2024

Colapinto has been integrated into the paddock through the Williams Driver Academy programme

Grand Prix Photo

It was also refreshing to learn that he has a proper appreciation of the sport’s history.

“I think Fangio and Senna have been the South Americans that left a big mark and legacy in our sport,” he noted. “And I just grew up with them, with the movies, with the books, with all the stories from them.

Related article

“I think in many moments I feel quite close to what happened to them, mainly to Senna. He went through I think many difficult stages, and I feel a bit representative with him, and I’d just love to understand a bit more the story, to see what he had to go through to get to F1 and to achieve so many successful moments. And it’s something that motivates me a lot to continue.”

The Abu Dhabi test went well, and strong early season F2 form contributed to Colapinto being handed an FP1 outing at Silverstone.

Usually those opportunities come later in the year, and in retrospect it can be viewed as a handy chance for the team to assess him in a higher pressure environment than the Abu Dhabi test.

“It was by far the best experience of my life,” he said after the Silverstone session. “There is only one first FP1. I’m very happy, mostly because I was able to enjoy every moment and to make the maximum out of it. I think you always have a feeling that you could have done more.

“I felt like I had much more room to improve in many, many corners. I think to be only four-tenths behind Alex, and he has so much experience in F1 and he has so much experience with the team, and he’s very well connected with the car, he has a lot of confidence, is good for me.”

Franco Colapinto Williams 2024 british GP FP1

Racking up the mileage in FP1 at Silverstone – will it pay dividends in Monza?

Grand Prix Photo

That FP1 outing impressed Williams, and now it’s down to what he can achieve on track over these nine races. He knows Monza and Abu Dhabi, but the rest of the venues are new to him. The upcoming street events in Baku and Singapore, and Las Vegas later in the year, will be particularly challenging.

In some ways he has nothing to lose, as for example he’s not fighting to secure an F1 race seat for 2025, unless he does something so sensational in the coming weeks that it sparks the interest of Sauber and Audi. It will be fascinating to see what he can achieve.