MPH: F1 journalists were never scared to report what they saw. That may be changing

F1
Mark Hughes
November 18, 2026

F1 journalists' freedom has been put under the spotlight after a reporter from the Daily Mail had his press pass withdrawn. The concerns are valid, writes Mark Hughes, but this incident hasn't helped the cause

Fred Vasseur with Daily Mail headlines

FIA withdrew Mail man's press pass after Leclerc article. Then came the follow-up about Ferrari team boss Fred Vasseur (pictured)

Mark Hughes
November 18, 2026

I’m in two minds about this particular column. Because it’s about the media of F1 rather than F1 itself. But I’ve decided to go ahead on the basis of there apparently being an interest in the subject of F1 media’s relationship to F1 – and how there seem to be many misconceptions. These misconceptions will for sure have only been given added weight by the recent stripping of the Daily Mail‘s F1 journalist of his paddock credentials for the last three races of this season.

First, let me say that in 26 years of covering F1 I have never had my credentials threatened by either the FIA or F1. Despite numerous pieces critical over the years of whatever situation the sport has found itself in. I once got an implied threat from Bernie Ecclestone, a joking ‘Do you feel safe here?’ that just let me know he was aware. But never any serious threat of credentials.

The common misconception among a big segment of F1 fans – if social media posts are any guide – is that the F1 media is terrified of saying anything negative for fear of loss of credentials: until earlier this year that belief was absolute nonsense, the sort of assumed invented rubbish that somehow takes a hold and becomes a general belief in the social media age. There was never even an implied threat and I certainly never felt constrained to write as I saw and I don’t think others did either.

Now, admittedly I have in the main been writing for specialist publications devoted to detailed analysis of F1 with a hardcore, F1-literate following. Those writing for a bigger, more general, audience may come under more scrutiny, I suspect.

Charles Leclerc stands in front of an FIA and F1 branded backdrop

FIA took action after criticism of Charles Leclerc

Artur Widak/NurPhoto via Getty

But until earlier this year I have not known of any respected journalistic outlet being threatened with loss of credentials. That’s over several decades. I’ve known of a few un-qualified chancers writing invented nonsense being kicked out. But no more than a couple in 26 years and quite justified.

But through several paddock sources, I know for a fact that earlier this year – in a story outside of the public domain – the FIA refused to grant press credentials to two journalists who had done nothing but report. What they were reporting was clearly not to the FIA’s approval. The edict came from the top.

If those particular passes were indeed denied for that reason, it raises a very serious question about press freedom. The sport’s credibility relies heavily upon a free press – and a free press includes by definition the freedom to express or imply criticism, or even just to report something which power would prefer not to be reported. Otherwise, the media would become just the PR branch of the sport – and therefore not to be taken seriously. These were two very concerning incidents.

Related article

The current Daily Mail FIA credential story is slightly different. What it has in common is the governing body playing a dangerous game with the sport’s credibility by using its power to limit access.  What is different is that the piece which triggered the ban was crass name-calling of a driver – followed up by more of the same about the driver’s boss – which went beyond journalistic professionalism. It was beyond articulating a criticism in an opinion column. It was infantile and way beyond what has ever been accepted as valid journalism. It was borrowing the worst way of expression from social media – and then calling foul when that was called out.

Given that the two incidents earlier in the year suggest an attempt at controlling the narrative by restricting access to anything deemed off-message, such a piece was disastrous for the cause of press freedom. If that’s how press freedom is to be used.

Formula 1 and the teams have initiated a great programme of being united against online abuse (see below) and now here was a journalist using the same sort of language as that which the sport is trying to curtail. It’s the journalism of hate and division in what is supposed to be a sport.

The FIA could have issued a statement along those lines for the world to see rather than pulling the pass. It has not reacted well here. But it was given licence to act in this way by an extremely inappropriate piece, with an even worse, more infantile follow-up.

This is totally different to being critical of the sport or asking difficult questions. This is not talking truth to power. It’s just standing on the sidelines shouting totally inappropriate insults to participants. Football terrace journalism.

There are two conflicting issues here. 1) Limiting press freedom. 2) The journalistic race to the bottom.

The first is potentially sinister as well as potentially damaging to the sport’s credibility. The second has given licence to deploy the first. If the FIA does have an agenda to limit criticism, fair or unfair, the piece in question has given it credible cover to act and say it’s to halt that race to the bottom. Even if that were not its real motivation.

So it’s incumbent upon all pass holders to express themselves with respect and civility even when being critical and to justify any critical claims in an articulate way. What the Mail pieces have done is weaken the defences against curtailment of press freedom. Not strengthened them.

Mark Hughes

Grand Prix editor

In previous lives Mark raced cars, worked at Jim Russell racing school, got a university degree which he never used, tried working in industry, didn’t like it, left and joined Motoring News in 1988 as a junior club race reporter. Went freelance in ’96, concentrated on F1 from 2000. Grand Prix editor of Autosport for 10 years.

More from Mark

You may also like