Can Red Bull be beaten to F1 title in 2024? Why history suggests not

F1

Red Bull has gone from strength to strength in the past three F1 seasons, but will 2024 be the year where it's beaten in the championship? History offers a strong suggestion...

Max Verstappen Red Bull 2023

Will Verstappen and the RB20 earn even more silverware in 2024?

Red Bull

Beat Red Bull. It’s the only target for F1 rivals with hopes of winning the championship. But given its supremacy in 2023, can any team hope to overhaul the reigning champions?

Given that Red Bull has won 86% of all grands prix since the last major regulation changes in 2022, the omens aren’t good. Its advantage only increased last year when the RB19 won 21 of 22 races, and with its dominance obvious from the start of the season, engineers would have been able to switch their attention to the RB20 relatively early in the year.

That’s the power of an established advantage and, as history shows, it’s a formidable force. It happened with Williams in the early 1990s; with Ferrari in the early-2000s; with Red Bull from 2010; and then Mercedes at the start of the hybrid era.

When one team pulls out an advantage over the rest of the grid, opponents rarely close the gap until the next set of major rule changes reset the equation, and it’s clear to see why. While the secrets of the 2022 Red Bull were exposed when Sergio Perez‘s crashed car was lifted high over Monaco’s streets, revealing the intricate ground-effect channels underneath, that only enabled other constructors to catch up to the previous year’s thinking, while the champions had already moved on — to last year’s dominant car.

Sergio Pérez’s crash at the 2022 Monaco GP

Some of Red Bull’s secrets spilled after Sergio Pérez’s crash at the 2022 Monaco Grand Prix

DPPI

Even in the modern era — where teams lower down in the championship gain increased aero testing time over those at the front — the budget cap limits their ability to invest in closing the gap.

Unless Red Bull has taken a calamitous change of direction, the chances of the team losing its spot at the front of the grid look slim.

From the archive

But, as the examples from F1’s past suggest below, so do Red Bull’s chances of maintaining its advantage when new regulations are introduced in 2026. Rarely does a team maintain an edge when new rules shake up the series — sometimes with the uncanny effect of neutering the leading team’s specific strength.

Red Bull faces a particularly tough challenge in 2026 as it adapts to new technical regulations that are likely to include smaller cars, while also developing its very first in-house engine. Having experienced first-hand a decade ago how a below-par engine can destroy years of success, it will be approaching the new F1 era with caution.

On the other hand, it does have Adrian Newey at the drawing board. Unequalled in his ability to spot the opportunities in a new rulebook, he’s been behind many of the cars that have dominated the past three decades. If anyone can buck the trend, it’s him — so don’t rule out another seven years, at least, of Red Bull success.

 

The teams that dominated modern F1

Williams
1992-1993

Nigel Mansell 1992 Williams FW14B

Mansell’s title-winning Williams FW14B — featuring active suspension

Grand Prix Photo

The Red Bull of the early 1990s, Williams had what looked to be an unassailable advantage thanks to the active suspension underpinning its Adrian Newey-designed car. Perfecting the continuously-adjusting hydraulics that maintained a constant ride height — for optimising aerodynamic performance — took the 1991 season, during which Williams still won the constructors’ championship and Nigel Mansell gave Senna a run for the title.

The investment really paid off in 1992. Mansell swept to the championship, winning the first five races, on his way to nine victories from 16 grands prix. As others scrambled to catch up, so drivers hotfooted it to Frank Williams’ door. Both Ayrton Senna and Alain Prost were lobbying for a 1993 seat, but the Frenchman won — with a clause that prevented Senna from becoming his team-mate.

From the archive

Williams once again prevailed, despite Senna’s valiant efforts, but the technology takeover was at an end. In the face of increasing speeds and reduced reliance on the driver, electronic aids were banned, consigning active suspension, along with anti-lock brakes, traction control and launch control to the scrapheap.

The result, in 1994, was that average lap times climbed by more than four seconds as a result. Williams lost its advantage and faced an up-and-coming Michael Schumacher in a speedy Benetton.

Williams would go on to win that year’s constructors’ title, and would regain its superiority later that decade, but Senna, having finally secured a seat with the team, was killed in a crash at Imola just three races into the new campaign.

Ferrari
2000-2005

Michael Schumacher left Benetton in 1995 after a second consecutive world championship to join the monumental effort of rebuilding Ferrari. Alongside team boss Jean Todt and technical director Ross Brawn, they succeeded where so many before them had failed — but only after years of near-misses, controversial collisions and a broken leg for Schumacher at Silverstone.

Related article

2002: the year Michael Schumacher described as ‘perfect’
F1

2002: the year Michael Schumacher described as 'perfect'

19 years ago today, Michael Schumacher completed a devastating title assault by winning the F1 drivers' crown faster than anyone else, a season which the maestro himself said couldn't be improved upon

By James Elson

The 1999 season brought a constructors’ title, despite Schumacher missing six grands prix due to his leg injury, and then came the run of victories. Ferrari and Schumacher clinched every F1 title between 2000 and 2004 in what was then a period of unprecedented dominance.

Once again, it was ended when a decisive advantage was removed: a last-minute decision ahead of the 2005 season banned tyre changes during races (except for in case of punctures). It badly hampered the The Maranello team which had worked in tandem with Bridgestone, which developed tyres that were tailored to Ferrari.

They wore quickly but were extremely fast — especially when bolted to Michael Schumacher‘s car. The German was no stranger to pitting more often than his rivals — who all ran the slower but more durable Michelin tyre — in order to counter any excessive tyre wear but he still managed to secure 48 race victories and five consecutive drivers’ world titles between 2000-2004.

But the implementation of the no pit-stop rule scuppered Ferrari’s strategy. As a result both Schumacher and team-mate Rubens Barrichello struggled in 2005, winning just one race and finishing a distant third in the constructors’ standings while the Michelin-running Renault captured both titles.

 

Red Bull
2010-2013

Red Bull 2010

Red Bull and Vettel were the class of the field in 2010 and beyond

Grand Prix Photo

Red Bull and Adrian Newey’s first period of dominance came after new 2009 rules introduced lower and wider front wings, higher and narrower rear wings and diffusers mounted further back. It was the Brawn team that got it right immediately, and built an unassailable lead. But Red Bull’s trio of wins in the final races of that season pointed to its impending success.

In 2010, the Newey-designed RB6 integrated a double diffuser (a feature which had allowed Brawn to dominate the previous year) with a blown exhaust — a system which could create more downforce at the rear of the car by redirecting jets of airflow.

From the archive

While many teams mounted their exhaust tailpipes within the diffuser — putting a greater burden on driver who had to control the amount of downforce available through different throttle inputs — Red Bull had its tailpipes lower, blowing air onto the diffuser from above which ‘sealed’ the edges’, maintaining a concentrated airflow at the diffuser exit to increase downforce.

Although there were challenges from McLaren and Ferrari, the team won every drivers’ and constructors’ championship from 2010 to 2013, with 13 wins from 19 races in the final season. But that established advantage wouldn’t continue in the new hybrid era. While Newey was on hand to work his aerodynamic magic with the new 2014 rulebook, the cars would all-too-often be trailing a cloud of white smoke from the hopeless new-spec Renault engines.

 

Mercedes
2014-2021

Preceding the superiority of Max Verstappen and Red Bull, Lewis Hamilton and Mercedes were the undisputed kings of the hybrid era — securing 8 constructors’ titles and 7 drivers’ titles from 2014 to 2021.

Much like the Milton Keynes marque, the key to Mercedes’ dominance was a fast start following the biggest set of regulations changes the series had ever seen — up to that point at least. In order to revitalise its sustainability efforts, F1 chose to switch from naturally aspirated V8s to turbocharged V6 hybrid engines and implemented the use of a new Energy Recovery System (ERS).

Mercedes invested heavily in developing its power unit prior to the change and had a massive advantage when the new era of cars hit the track for the first time in Melbourne. Hamilton — who had joined from McLaren the year before — took pole position by three-tenths of a second and team-mate Nico Rosberg won the race 25 seconds clear of the trailing field.

Mercedes 2014 F1 Australian Grand Prix

Powered by a new hybrid engine, Mercedes were quicker than anyone else in 2014

Grand Prix Photo

Mercedes was then able to build on its head-start in the years to come, and won 110 races out of the next 159 — four times as many as the next best team during the same period (27).

A change to the regulations for the 2021 season, in a bid to reduce downforce and slow cars down, had a disproportionate effect on Mercedes, but the team remianed competitive. It won that season’s constructors’ title but Red Bull’s performance was on a par and the drivers’ title went down to the wire. It was decided, famously, in Abu Dhabi.

 

Team’s performance in final year of dominance vs under new regulations

F1’s dominant teams Drivers’ titles Constructors’ titles Wins Pole positions 
Williams (1992-1993) 2 (100%) 2 (100%) 19 (59%) 30 (94%)
Active suspension banned
Ferrari (2000-2004) 5 (100%) 5 (100%) 57 (67%) 51 (60%)
Tyre changes banned
Red Bull (2010-2013) 4 (100%) 4 (100%) 40 (52%) 52 (68%)
Hybrid power units introduced
Mercedes (2014-2020) 7 (100%) 7 (100%) 102 (74%) 109 (79%)
Floor area reduced, followed by ground effect regulations in 2022
Red Bull (2022-) 2 (100%) 2 (100%) 38 (86%) 22 (50%)
?